5 Proven Email Subject Lines to Ask for Review / Testimonial

A compelling customer story can spark more engagement than any marketing pitch. Subject lines like “[First name], these results speak louder than promises” or “Before and after: watch revenue climb 32 percent for Sarah’s shop” bring the human angle front and center.

In this guide, I will share proven subject lines for requesting customer testimonials, so you can start creating your own customer stories.

Real story: how [customer name] saved 40 hours with us

Case Study Review / Testimonial Requests

You tap human curiosity here. Readers love specifics, so “40 hours” feels concrete, not hype.

Social proof lifts open rates because 89% of people trust recommendations from people they know.

Schedule this line inside a weekly customer‑story drip, right after onboarding finishes, when fresh users still compare options.

Inside the email I suggest adding a:

  • Three‑step timeline
  • One hero quote
  • A prominent “Try the shortcut” button.

Clear number, clear outcome, clear next move, and customers will appreciate that.

Type

Social Proof, Case Study

Tone

Inspiring, data‑driven, matter‑of‑fact

Example Email

Hi [first name],

Remember those late nights juggling reports?

Alex from FintechCo shaved two full workdays each month after switching to our template.

Tap to watch the two‑minute walk‑through.

Show me the workflow

Talk soon,
Customer Success Team

See why 1,203 users just rated us five stars

Case Study Review / Testimonial Requests

Big, round numbers inspire trust, but the word “just” indicates new information, which is better than stale praise.

Automated flows that feature social proof outperform bulk campaigns.

Use this subject line after a feature release so the new score feels earned.

Inside, embed a scrolling marquee of snippets, each limited to 120 characters for fast scanning.

A final CTA nudges readers to “Browse all reviews” which keeps compliance teams happy by avoiding cherry‑picking only glowing lines.

Type

Review Highlight, Community Proof

Tone

Excited, evidence‑based, upbeat

[first name], these results speak louder than promises

Automated Review / Testimonial Requests

Talk directly to the subscriber, then pivot from claims to evidence.

I suggest setting up a triggered email to be sent when a lead views the pricing pages twice but does not make a purchase.

Inside, a quick chart contrasts “Before” and “After” metrics from a peer brand.

I would cap the copy at 110 words and place two bold numbers front and center. Visual proof plus personal address reduces doubt and nudges the hesitant visitor toward a demo slot.

Type

Personalized Proof, Re-engagement

Tone

Confident, persuasive, conversational

Before and after: watch revenue climb 32% for Sarah’s shop

Case Study Motivational Review / Testimonial Requests

Type

Success Snapshot, Storytelling

Tone

Narrative, motivating, friendly

Readers lean in when they spot a friendly name. Consumers (around 30%) trust reviews as much as personal recommendations from friends and family, so pairing a percentage with a relatable owner amplifies credibility.

Pair the subject line with a 30‑second GIF showing Sarah’s dashboard tick upward.

Beneath, keep the prose plain: what problem she faced, what action she tried, what result emerged.

A single “Replicate Sarah’s playbook” button to drive clicks.

Can we share your success story next?

Request Review / Testimonial Requests

This kind of testimonial email subject line flips the script by celebrating the reader first, then politely asking for a quote.

User‑generated content carries a lot of weight.

Send this email 30 days after purchase, when satisfaction is at its peak. Inside, provide three simple ways to share: a quick form, a five-minute call, or a selfie with the product.

End with a sincere thank-you paragraph because gratitude, not bribery, earns genuine praise.

 

Type

Engagement Request, Testimonial Collection

Tone

Invitational, appreciative, human

Turn Your WordPress Site Into a Full Helpdesk - No Coding Needed

Try Heroic Inbox risk free